Teachers' Guide to Charter Schools vs Public Schools

Written by Sasha Blakeley

Charter Schools vs. Public Schools

When teachers finish their education and training, one of the most significant decisions they need to make is where to work. The majority of teachers work at public schools, but some will take positions at charter schools. Teachers must understand what charter schools are and how they differ from public schools. There are advantages and disadvantages to working at both kinds of schools that may influence a teacher's ultimate decision. Disentangling public perceptions of charter and public schools compared to the actual data about these schools is very important for those who want to ensure that they have a complete picture of the current educational landscape before they start applying to teach in a new school.

The charter school vs. public schools distinction impacts the work environment for teachers and the educational environment for students. Teachers will likely have their own priorities and their own teaching philosophy; those traits will probably align more closely with either the public school system or the charter school system. It is important to note that there is a great deal of diversity between charter schools and public schools; individual teachers may have highly varied experiences in these institutions. All the differences and similarities described here are general trends, not universals. Some public and some charter schools will likely fall outside the usual parameters. Nonetheless, having a broad understanding of how each kind of school works can be a helpful asset for teachers.

What are Charter Schools?

Charter schools are a specific kind of school separate from the usual public and private school systems. These schools operate outside of the traditional public school paradigm. They are publicly funded and are connected to a charter school authorizer that can be a college, an NGO, or an educational agency. They abide by a charter to determine their educational commitments and regulations but are not bound to state or regional educational specifications. Their authorizer ensures they follow their charter's rules. Charter school students often still need to take standardized tests and other general markers of educational progress to see how the charter school measures up against other educational options. Charter schools do need to be accredited educational institutions committed to high standards of teaching, which means students who attend charter schools can get a high school diploma just like any other student.

According to data from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), there are currently approximately 7,500 charter schools. Nationwide, around 3.4 million elementary and secondary students attend charter schools. Charter schools have existed in the US since 1992, though the idea behind them was proposed several years earlier. They have grown in popularity over time as an alternative to either public or private educational models. Most charter schools are located in urban environments, although some are in suburban and rural areas, and their access is expanding. Because charter schools are run by independent organizations, a relatively high number of charter schools close after just a few years if they find that they are not based on a sustainable model. A focus on attending or working at well-established charter schools with a good reputation is a good idea for students and teachers, respectively.

Are Charter Schools Public or Private?

Although charter schools have existed for several decades, they differ from public and private schools in ways that make them challenging to understand. Are charter schools public? Are they private? Are charter schools free for students? These questions do not always have straightforward yes or no answers. Charter schools are not private; they are free for students to attend and are expressly forbidden from charging students tuition fees. Charter schools also cannot be affiliated with a particular religion. However, they also exist outside of the regular public school system. They are not beholden to state regulations, meaning the curriculum at a charter school can be significantly different than at a normal public school. Some charter schools are deliberately experimental in their curriculum approach, diverging from public schools on the length of school days or the languages of instruction.

What is the Difference Between Public Schools and Charter Schools?

There are several differences between public schools and charter schools. The experience of attending a charter school as a student may be very different from attending a public school. Many lists of charter schools vs. public school facts will cite higher academic performance standards or differences in student demographics at charter schools. There is some truth to those claims, but research suggests that things are actually more complicated than they may initially appear. Some potential differences between the two types of schools are shown in the table below.

Charter Schools Public Schools
Flexible curriculum Adherence to state standards
Limited special needs support Support for students with disabilities
Teacher training requirements vary Teachers must be licensed
Teacher unions usually restricted Teacher unions common

These differences are generalizations; each school is different, and teachers should research individual schools to learn more about their policies and educational environments. Charter schools and public schools can be highly varied in their approaches to education, standards, budget, and ability to create a positive and inclusive learning environment for students. Some students may thrive in a charter school environment but struggle in public school; others may have the opposite experience. The same is true of teachers. A closer look at performance standards and demographics in each type of school can help elucidate some of the differences between these two approaches to learning.

Charter Schools Performance vs. Public Schools

Charter schools have a widespread reputation for having higher standards of educational performance than public schools. They can set their own curriculum, and many deliberately seek out teachers who specialize in certain subjects. Some charter schools focus on STEM subjects, teach students a second language, or allow students to pursue their areas of interest in the classroom. For some students, this can lead to improved academic performance. Evidence suggests students from low-income backgrounds and English language learners (ELLs) do better in schools when they can attend charter schools over public schools.

Some studies have been less optimistic about charter school students' achievement levels. In standardized tests, a study based in New York City found comparable proficiency rates in math and English at both public and charter schools; in fact, charter school students tended to score slightly lower than their public school counterparts. There were some outliers to these results — some charter schools did manage exceptional student achievement — but the significant boost in student grades that many expect from charter schools was not clear across the board. The variation in charter school curricula and standards may result in less consistent student achievement than one might hope.

Student Demographic Differences

One of the significant differences between public and charter schools regarding student experiences is the demographic makeup of these schools. In accordance with federal law, public schools are required to provide accessible education to students with disabilities. Charter schools are also subject to this law, but since they operate outside the public school system and are accountable to private regulatory bodies, it is more difficult to enforce charter schools' disability education policy. Students with disabilities may therefore be less likely to be able to attend charter schools even if they would like to, as there is no guarantee that their specific needs will be met.

Charter schools tend to have fewer students with disabilities than public schools because of this regulatory difference, according to the Center on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE). Part of this difference may come from parents worrying that their children will receive insufficient support and choosing not to apply to charter schools in the first place. With a less diverse population, teachers may have less incentive to create inclusive classrooms that meet all students' needs. This can be a significant downside to charter schools for many students. Students with disabilities are less likely to benefit from the academic and extra-curricular programs charter schools offer. Students who acquire a disability during their schooling may have to transfer schools if their charter school is unable or unwilling to accommodate their needs.

Pros and Cons of Charter Schools for Teachers

There are many pros and cons of charter schools and public schools for teachers. What works best for one teacher may not be ideal for another, as everyone has a unique background and specific employment needs and expectations. It can also be hard to generalize about charter schools because they are, by definition, diverse in their approaches to education. Public schools can also be highly variable: the amount of funding they receive, their student demographics, and even their location can dramatically alter the experience that teachers will have when they work there. Similarly, something that sounds like a downside for some teachers may be an advantage for others. Examining the differences between charter schools and public schools with an open mind is vital for anyone approaching this major career decision.

Training Requirements

To become a public school teacher, an individual must start by earning an undergraduate degree from an accredited teacher training program. That degree must usually be in education or the subject or subjects the individual wants to teach once they complete their training. After completing a degree, aspiring teachers will need to pass a licensing exam. The PRAXIS exam is the teacher certification test used across much of the country. Depending on their state of residence, teachers may have to take other exams instead of or in addition to the PRAXIS test. It usually takes several months to prepare for teacher licensing exams; this can be a stressful time for new teachers.

Some states require teachers to complete a portfolio demonstrating their teaching capabilities before they can be granted a teaching license. After finishing these educational elements, teachers must also complete their state's student teaching requirements. Student teaching involves working in a real classroom alongside an established educator for several months or sometimes up to a full school year. At the end of this process, teachers can start working full-time in a public school in their state. Teachers work hard to receive their licenses, and many are keen to work in a position that allows them to demonstrate that achievement.

Charter schools do not have the same training requirements as public schools. Many require their teachers to be fully licensed, but not all. Teachers who have come to their profession through an unorthodox educational pathway may not meet all of the requirements for teaching in their state but might still be talented educators with specific areas of specialization. Charter school teacher requirements will vary from school to school, so it is essential for teachers interested in working for a particular school to research that school's employment parameters and prerequisites before coming to a final decision.

Salary and Work Schedule

One potential upside to working at a charter school is that teachers working in these environments may earn slightly higher salaries than their counterparts at public schools. Evidence on charter school salaries varies; some schools do pay their teachers better than comparable public schools, while others do not. This is another area where teachers should do their research before accepting a position at any charter school. Because funding for charter schools comes from varying sources, the budget for paying teachers can be quite high or relatively low. Data from a 2012 Michigan study actually found that charter school teachers made an average of $42,864 per year, while public school teachers in the state made $63,094 in the same school year.

Charter schools tend to run on different schedules from public schools. On average, they have more school days per year than public schools, meaning their teachers should be prepared to have fewer vacation days. Because charter schools often have a strong focus on academics and experimental curricula, they sometimes expect their teachers to work longer hours than public school educators. The NCES found that charter school teachers tend to work slightly more hours per week than public school teachers. Not all charter schools work this way, but a lack of regulation of labor at charter schools does mean that teachers' hours may be less closely monitored than at a public school.

Unionization

Teachers' unions are important for educators to ensure they have collective bargaining power at work. Unions can help teachers secure higher pay, better benefits, increased workplace protections, and more. They offer a form of protection that can be very valuable. Public school teachers are almost always either unionized or have the option to unionize. Charter schools can place more restrictions on their teachers' unionization efforts, meaning that charter school teachers are much less likely to unionize. Only around ten percent of charter schools are currently unionized. While a lack of mandatory union dues may seem attractive to younger teachers, the lack of union-led stability and protection can lead to less job stability and more potential for workplace exploitation in the future.

Curriculum Flexibility

Charter schools pride themselves on their flexible curricula, as they are not bound by state education requirements. Their charter requires them to maintain high educational standards, so their lack of adherence to state requirements does not result in an ''anything goes'' attitude. They aim to provide high-quality education for students without being restricted to a specific set of textbooks or other materials. This flexibility is one of the great strengths of charter schools. They can offer students a more specialized high school experience than most public schools. Some charter schools function as college preparatory programs. Some have a heavy emphasis on the arts, athletics, or sciences. Some charter schools might offer distinctive academic programs that fit a certain subset of students, making them an appealing and free alternative to public schools.

For teachers, just as for students, the curriculum can be one of the primary benefits of charter schools. Teachers at charter schools are often given a lot of freedom to adapt their curriculum to suit their students' needs and their own areas of expertise. Teachers interested in exploring various pedagogical theories might find it easier to implement those theories in a charter school classroom. A charter school that can allocate specific funding to enable teacher creativity could be a great place to try out project-based learning, universal design for learning, inclusive teaching, and other up-and-coming teaching strategies.

Teachers who want to work in an environment that can support their interests and help them provide a unique learning experience to students may find that charter schools are the best fit for them. Anyone in this position will need to carefully examine the charter schools in their local area to see which ones best suit their own vision for education. During this research process, it is a good idea to ask specific questions about how the charter school organizes its curriculum and how it can support teachers' efforts in the classroom. It is also important for teachers to remember that public schools can be open to new pedagogical theories and may also value teachers' efforts to incorporate unique learning approaches. Every school is different, and every teacher's journey to find the best school for them will follow a unique path.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the disadvantages of charter schools?

    Charter schools are less likely to let teachers unionize and may ask for longer work hours for lower pay. They are not regulated by the state, so the education and employment opportunities that they offer can be inconsistent.

  • What are the pros and cons of charter schools?

    Charter schools can offer a flexible curriculum that can be a great choice for students and teachers. They may offer their teachers a lower salary and fewer workplace protections than public schools.

  • Why are charter schools controversial?

    Charter schools are controversial for several reasons. They may be less likely to offer comprehensive special needs education, often prevent their teachers from unionizing, and do not consistently produce better academic results than public schools.

  • Why do charter schools perform better?

    There is a widespread public perception that charter schools perform better than public schools, and some do; this is often due to an innovative curriculum and a clear educational vision. However, many charter schools perform the same or slightly worse than their public school counterparts.